County supervisors unanimously advance cattle-grazing proposal
Longhorn and Corriente cattle wait in the pen before the cattle drive File photo by Chris Stone The San Diego County Board of Supervisors unanimously advanced a proposal on Wednesday that was intended to exempt sustainable cattle-grazing from a grading and clearing ordinance and expand ranching operations on county-owned land By a - vote they directed the chief administrative officer along with county staff to find options as requested by Supervisor Jim Desmond CAO Ebony Shelton and the Planning Progress Services would have six months to prepare a list of options According to information on the Wednesday board agenda the county will get input from ranchers and industry advocates environmental groups and local fire protection agencies Desmond mentioned that based on ranchers feedback there are growing concerns about regulatory burdens surrounding required grading and clearing permits for cattle grazing At one time such requirements may have been appropriate particularly to address the impacts of poorly managed grazing practices on the local ecosystems Desmond declared However over the past several decades ranchers have made considerable advances in sustainable land management and multiple rotate grazing and maintain limited herd sizes which allows for grazing areas to recover resulting in stronger and more resilient landscapes he added Desmond noted that ranchers play a role in land conservation Cattle grazing can offer real land management co-benefits as opposed to more intensive land maturation he mentioned Supporting a vibrant ranching industry reduces reliance on external supply chains for beef Desmond mentioned We should not only acknowledge the valuable contributions the ranchers make to our communities but should consider ourselves fortunate to have a strong ranching presence in the county he added Vice Chair Terra Lawson-Remer revealed she had no principal objections to Desmond s proposal which she described as fascinating I don t want us to end up with policies that don t make sense because we haven t consulted with a broad enough group of stakeholders she noted Lawson-Remer added that given their efforts on major issues such as faster housing production she longed to ensure LUEG staffers would have the necessary time to present options to the Board of Supervisors One county official responded that while it will take additional staff hours staffers can handle the task During community comment the majority speakers including San Marcos Mayor Rebecca Jones and agriculture industry representatives were supportive of changing the grazing procedures Andy Lyle a San Diego County Farm Bureau member stated animal grazing can improve soil wellness and structure Lyle commented livestock manure adds nutrients and organic matter to the soil while their hooves help incorporate plant material and seeds into the ground Lyle added that rotational grazing allows soil to better receive rainfall reducing runoff and erosion An official with the Pool Conservation District of Greater San Diego County reported the state ruling body in the form of a Senate Bill also supports this type of grazing on population lands Categorizing cattle grazing as degrading would be a mistake and missed opportunity added Joel Kramer Further he added that sustainable grazing is connected to the resurgence of certain endangered species such as the burrowing owls and tricolored blackbird Katie Ostrander a rancher and Warner Springs resident mentioned it was central to keep grazing land in good shape for wildlife and cattle alike We recognize that the land s ecosystem is fragile and interconnected disclosed Ostrander a member of San Diego County Cattlewomen Dan Silver of the Endangered Habitats League reported his group was conceptually in favor of a viable grazing plan change but added there are harms as well as benefits to grazing The environmental group doesn t want ordinance exemptions be a predetermined preordained outcome Silver declared There would need to be strict best management practices and site selection criteria for this to be effective Silver the group s executive director suggested the county work with the University of California Agriculture Extension and use a rangeland consultant to assist on agenda rather than burden county land-use employees
